1 - Russell Hoult

Appearances: 0+1 (L), 1 (CC)
Clean Sheets: 0
Yellow Cards: 0
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 6.00
MOMs: 0

Russell Hoult has served West Bromwich Albion well, but we may well have seen his last game in an Albion shirt. That statement could be in doubt given that there is a possibility that both Kirkland and Kuszczak could start next season away from the Hawthorns, but even that is unlikely to save Hoult from a Hawthorns exit. A loan spell at Nottingham Forest was cut short when Kirkland got injured, but he was fortunate to get one Premiership appearance by being on the bench when Kuszczak suffered an injury at Fulham - Kirkland was ill. In truth, Russell has not been the same 'keeper since he suffered a back injury last season and, at 34, the seems little chance that he will rediscover his best form.

^ Back to Top


2 - Riccardo Scimeca

Appearances: 2 (L), 1+1 (CC)
Goals: 0
Yellow Cards: 0
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 6.25
MOMs: 0

Scimeca was always going to be on the fringe of the squad once Robson signed Steve Watson, who offers the same flexibility in positions as Riccy but is vastly more experienced and is a better all-round player. Scimeca finally joined Cardiff on a free transfer in January following a successful loan spell and his departure was hardly noticed.

^ Back to Top


3 - Paul Robinson

Appearances: 33 (L), 2 (CC), 1 (FAC)
Goals: 0
Yellow Cards: 8
Red Cards: 1

Average Rating: 6.59
MOMs: 0

A string of impressive performances last season and early this season led Bryan Robson to suggest that Paul Robinson should be considered for England given the injury problems that Cole and Bridge were experienced, but his occasional rashness means that he is unlikely ever to make it to international level. Robinson is an excellent defender, but the single-mindedness and self-belief that has got him to the position of being comfortable at Premiership level can be his downfall. His belief that he will win every challenge has left him with a string of red an yellow cards that has spoiled a decent season, not to mention a few dreadful errors that have cost Albion goals.

His commitment can never be questioned and he is the one Albion player you always know you will get 100% from - if he can add a little cool-headedness to the fire in his heart, he could be one of the best. I'm not holding my breath, though.

^ Back to Top


4 - Thomas Gaardsoe

Appearances: 7 (L), 2 (CC), 1 (FAC)
Goals: 0
Yellow Cards: 2
Red Cards: 1

Average Rating: 5.63
MOMs: 0

As good as Tommy was last season, it was clear early on this season that something was missing. Whether the injury that he has been struggling with all season is to blame for his poor form, I'm not sure, but having been under the knife since the end of the season, we call wait to see how he will perform back in the second tier of English football. If he can reproduce the form that saw him win my Player of the Season two years ago, he will be a huge asset.

^ Back to Top


5 - Williams Martinez

Appearances: 1+1 (L)
Goals: 1
Yellow Cards: 1
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 6.50
MOMs: 0

You have to feel sorry for Martinez. He's brought over from Uruguay on the advice of Daniel Fonseca but fails to get any real chance in the first team, apparently because of a language problem. And then, when he does get a chance, he's put in an unfamiliar left wing back role in Albion's worst defeat of the season. But then he caps it all with a goal on his first start for the club, in the last game of the season, and spoils by giving away a penalty with a rash challenge in the last minute.

It's difficult to know whether Robson's decision to release him was the right one given the amount we have seen him, but his lack of opportunity meant that it was always on the cards despite his last day heroics. One does have to question the logic of bringing him to the Hawthorns in the first place.

^ Back to Top


6 - Neil Clement

Appearances: 29+2 (L), 3 (CC)
Goals: 1
Yellow Cards: 4
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 6.00
MOMs: 1

It's nearly six years since Neil Clement first joined Albion on loan from Chelsea in 2000, and he still seems unable to quite fulfil the promise he has always shown. His conversion to a centre back last season seemed to have been a revelation, but he has struggled to match those performances this season despite having the steady rock of Curtis Davies alongside him. Moreover, one huge part of his game, scoring from free kicks, seems to have disappeared from his game. His last successful free kick was the deflected effort at Blackburn on the opening day of last season.

His form this season has been very up and down mainly due to a lack of concentration and, while I think he should be an asset in the Championship next season, he is likely to be little more than a squad player should we return to the Premiership.

^ Back to Top


7 - Nigel Quashie

Appearances: 9 (L)
Goals: 1
Yellow Cards: 1
Red Cards: 1

Average Rating: 6.11
MOMs: 1

We will never know whether Nigel Quashie could have been the signing to keep Albion up. The signs from his debut against Blackburn were good, but that moment of madness against Middlesbrough denied Albion of his services for five crucial games, and played a part in condemning Quashie to his second successive relegation. Nigel has the ability to be a huge asset to Albion but he needs to cut out those red mist moments that have marred his career so far. He is a strong skilful midfielder that should perform well in the Championship next season, and he certainly has a lot to make up for in the eyes of the Baggies faithful. Let's hope he can do it.

^ Back to Top


8 - Jonathan Greening

Appearances: 37+1 (L), 1 (CC), 2 (FAC)
Goals: 2
Yellow Cards: 2
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 6.40
MOMs: 5

Despite opening his Albion account against Wigan, Jonno had a poor first half of the season as he struggled to reproduce the excellent crosses that gave him the best record of assists outside the top three Premiership clubs last season. However, his form in the last few months of the season was much improved, although the poor form of the strikers meant that it was not enough to alter the final outcome. If he stays, he will be one of the best crossers of the ball in the Championship and should play a major part in Albion's promotion push.

^ Back to Top


9 - Geoff Horsfield

Appearances: 10+8 (L), 1 (CC), 0+1 (FAC)
Goals: 4
Yellow Cards: 2
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 6.06
MOMs: 2

Having scored the vital first goal on Survival Sunday, the Horse started this season by scoring Albion's first four goals before his form dropped. He eventually lost his place and didn't regain it until Kanu and Kamara had departed to the ACN in January. He put in a couple of good performances before Jeremy Peace received an offer from Sheffield United that he felt he could not turn down for a 32-year-old and he was on his way back up north.

His treatment by Neil Warnock since he arrived there has been shoddy and I hope that Geoff can get his career back on track. He has always given his all for every club he has played for and he will be fondly remembered at the Hawthorns. His departure was shrouded with controversy and many will argue that Geoff could have made the difference in scoring the goals to keep Albion up, but it is never that clear cut.

I was sorry to see him go, but I understand why he went. Good luck in future, Geoff.

^ Back to Top


10 - Andy Johnson

Appearances: 8 (L)
Goals: 0
Yellow Cards: 1
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 5.75
MOMs: 0

You always know what you will get from Andy Johnson, but the surprise was that we got as much as we did this season. His early season form showed that he was not about to turn in to the quality battling midfielder we desperately needed and he was relegated to the sidelines. Uncomplaining and hard working, he was rewarded by a couple of surprise recalls in the second half of the season, but the reality of the situation is that he is likely to leave the Hawthorns this summer, with his home town of Bristol the likely destination. AJ has been a great servant to the club, his commitment never in doubt, only his ability. I wish him all the best.

^ Back to Top


11 - Zoltan Gera
Appearances: 12+3 (L), 0+1(FAC)
Goals: 3
Yellow Cards: 1
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 6.19
MOMs: 0

It has been a nightmare season for the Magic Magyar, and it would be hugely unfair on Albion fans if it is to be his last at the Hawthorns. His absence from the side for much of the season is one of the biggest reasons why Albion will not be playing Premiership football next season. He was such a huge influence on Albion last season that the effect of his being out of the side cannot be underestimated. His performance against Everton on the last day of the season was a glimpse of what Albion had been missing.

I'm sure that Gera will want to stay at the Hawthorns, but the question is whether the pressure to play in the top flight from his sponsors and his agent will come to bear. All Albion fans wait anxiously for the answer.

^ Back to Top


12 - Richard Chaplow
Appearances: 4+3 (L), 1+2 (CC), 1 (FAC)
Goals: 2
Yellow Cards: 1
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 6.56
MOMs: 1

I was surprised that Chappers failed to really figure this season, especially given Albion's problems in finding a consistent central midfield combination. After scoring twice in the FA Cup game at Reading, he went out on loan to Southampton where he was, by all reports, pretty impressive. He has returned to the Hawthorns determined to fight his way into the first team, which shows an excellent attitude, and I expect him to figure more regularly next season.

^ Back to Top


13 - Jan Kozak
Appearances: 4+2 (L)
Goals: 0
Yellow Cards: 0
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 6.17
MOMs: 0

Although he looked good on the ball, Kozak was ultimately deemed not up to the demands of Premiership football, particularly in terms of the speed of the game. In a relegation fight, he was never going to be given the time to settle into life in this toughest of leagues and, as with Martinez, one has to question the wisdom of bringing him to the club in the first place.

^ Back to Top


14 - Martin Albrechtsen
Appearances: 26+5 (L), 2 (CC), 2 (FAC)
Goals: 1
Yellow Cards: 2
Red Cards: 1

Average Rating: 6.36
MOMs: 1

It's fair to say that Alby has not really lived up to his considerable fee although he has been a valuable member of the squad. His pace has offered one of the few attacking outlets for Albion this season and his defending has generally been steady. It's difficult to believe that he will make a top class defender, but he is still young and has time to improve, and will certainly be an asset in the Championship.

However, if the comments attributed to him regarding his desire to stay in the Premiership are correct, it certainly puts a huge question mark over his commitment to the club.

^ Back to Top


15 - Diomansay Kamara

Appearances: 21+5 (L), 3 (CC)
Goals: 2
Yellow Cards: 3
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 6.31
MOMs: 1

Pacy, skilful, but woeful in front of goal would adequately sum up Joe's season. He scored a wonderful goal to cap a wonderful performance against Man City in December, but most Albion fans are likely to remember his failure to convert a gilt-edged chance at St Andrew's. Kamara has a devastating turn of speed and some wonderful skills, but in terms of end product he is sorely lacking. He has youth on his side, and certainly has great potential, but he must realise it soon if he is to be a success.

If he is up for a season in the Championship, it could well do him a lot of good as he is likely to have far more chances against poorer defences - chances to hone his finishing skills.

^ Back to Top


16 - Steve Watson
Appearances: 28+2 (L), 1 (CC)
Goals: 1
Yellow Cards: 4
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 6.23
MOMs: 0

There is little doubt that Watson has been an asset to the club this season, even if his performances have not always been good enough. His experience and versatility have been very useful although his occasional lapses have been costly. It's difficult to put a finger on where Steve has gone wrong other than the two key words for defenders - consistency and concentration. Some of his mistakes should not be committed by a player of his experience, but commit them he has. On the other hand, he has put in some great performances, both at right back and in central midfield.

He may have the option to play in the Premiership next season and, while he would be a useful player to have around next season, it would be not disaster should he be allowed to move on.

^ Back to Top


17 - Darren Carter
Appearances: 11+9 (L), 3 (CC), 2 (FAC)
Goals: 1
Yellow Cards: 3
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 5.70
MOMs: 0

The subject of Darren Carter is one that is sure to spark debate amongst any group of Albion fans. He will always be a hero for Blues fans having scored the penalty that secured their promotion in 2002, and many were sorry to see him go, but despite the wonderful winner against Arsenal, Albion fans do not hold him in the same high esteem. Gera's extended absence meant that Carter got most of his opportunities on the left wing, a position that he was clearly uncomfortable in playing. It was no coincidence that Carter's best performances, such as the one against Spurs in December, were when he played in a more central position

He is young enough that he can recover from this disappointing season, and an extended spell in a central midfield position is what he needs to win over the fans. He should get a chance next season.

^ Back to Top


18 - Lloyd Dyer
Appearances: 0+1 (FAC)
Goals: 0
Yellow Cards: 0
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 6.00
MOMs: 0

After several loan spells and a solitary substitute appearance in the FA Cup, it was no surprise to see Lloyd Dyer sold to Millwall before his contract there was cancelled for family reasons. Albion fans will fondly remember his impact in the latter stages of the 2003-2004 season and wish him well for the future.

^ Back to Top


19 - Curtis Davies
Appearances: 33 (L), 2 (FAC)
Goals: 2
Yellow Cards: 0
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 6.79
MOMs: 9

Curtis Davies was a big surprise signing on the last day of the transfer window last summer, and he has been the one unqualified successful signing for Bryan Robson this season. He took to Premiership football immediately and has been a rock at the centre of the Albion defence ever since with a string of impressive performances. At 21, he is not yet the finished article and did make one or two errors during the season, but he has the potential to be an England regular in the future.

A big bid could prise him away from the Hawthorns this summer, but if Albion can hold onto him, he will be a major part of Albion's promotion push next season.

^ Back to Top


20 - Chris Kirkland
Appearances: 10 (L), 2 (FAC)
Clean Sheets: 1
Yellow Cards: 0
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 7.50
MOMs: 3

The season started so well for Chris Kirkland. The move to Albion seemed to have given him the opportunity to play regularly and a number of excellent displays had won him a place in the England squad once more. But then, injury struck once again just before another England friendly, and The Pole in Goal managed to establish himself as the Albion Number 1. A broken finger late on in the season has further strengthened his reputation as an injury jinx.

His future is uncertain as Liverpool have said he can leave and he has apparently had offers from Premiership clubs. He is unlikely to want to spend another season as second fiddle to Kuszczak, so he may look to move elsewhere. He remains an excellent 'keeper, and will surely one day get that elusive England cap.

^ Back to Top


21 - Kevin Campbell
Appearances: 19+10 (L), 0+1 (CC), 0+1 (FAC)
Goals: 3
Yellow Cards: 1
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 5.61
MOMs: 0

Campbell emerged this season as a hate figure for some Albion fans - a symbol of all that has been wrong with Robson's management this season. Often ineffective, it is easy to see why KC has been unpopular, and his dressing room presence so lauded last season does not appear to have had the same effect this term. For all that, Campbell has produced some good displays this season even if his goal tally is nowhere near what it should be, but he was used far more than he should have been.

Nonetheless, he has always given his best and his attitude is always first class. Whether he will feature in the playing squad next season, I'm not sure, but I wouldn't be surprised to see him offered a coaching role of some sort.

^ Back to Top


22 - Nathan Ellington
Appearances: 15+16 (L), 2 (CC), 2 (FAC)
Goals: 8
Yellow Cards: 0
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 5.94
MOMs: 0

The Duke joined in late August as one of the top strikers outside the top division - a season at the Hawthorns has done little to enhance his reputation. Personally, I believe Ellington has the capability of scoring goals at any level, but like many strikers, he is a confidence player, and he has struggled to score in a struggling side when he is only getting one or two chances a game. The longer the scoreless streak went on, the greater the pressure and the more difficult it became.

Noone outside the club knows the exact circumstances surrounding his toe injury, and his apparent unwillingness to play against Bolton, but the affair hardly made the Duke many friends amongst Albion fans. Rumours of his desire to return to Wigan have not helped the situation either, but if he is still around come August, I will be giving him my full support because I believe he can be a great goalscorer for the Baggies.

^ Back to Top


23 - Robert Earnshaw
Appearances: 4+8 (L), 2+1 (CC), 1 (FAC)
Goals: 3
Yellow Cards: 0
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 6.07
MOMs: 0

The Earnie argument ran and ran and continues to divide Albion fans five months after he left the club. My opinion is that he was perhaps not given enough of a chance this season, but his attitude was highly unprofessional. His game had its flaws, and not just in relation to his workrate off the ball. His movement and anticipation in the box was lacking at times which meant that he failed to get into the right position often enough - he should have scored more goals than he did. Personally, I think Robson should have accepted defeat in his fight to keep him much earlier than he did, which would have perhaps yielded a good bid earlier in the window, allowing time to find a replacement.

But it is all water under the bridge, and suffice to say thanks for your goals last season, Earnie, see you next season. I'm sure he'll manage to find the net against us!!

^ Back to Top


24 - Ronnie Wallwork
Appearances: 31 (L), 2 (CC), 2 (FAC)
Goals: 0
Yellow Cards: 11
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 6.79
MOMs: 7

Ronnie was a target for the boo boys again early on in the season as his form dropped from the heights he achieved last year. Robson certainly should have dropped him earlier, but after a couple of games out, Ronnie returned to perform much like he did last season and became one of the most consistent performers once more. The one dramatic change in Ronnie's game has been the number of bookings he has picked up. It seems that in an attempt to be a little more aggressive, he has incurred the wrath of the referees and suffered two suspensions this season as a result.

Nonetheless, it was generally another great season for Ronnie after those early season wobbles.

^ Back to Top


25 - Nwankwo Kanu
Appearances: 17+8 (L), 1+1 (CC), 1 (FAC)
Goals: 6
Yellow Cards: 0
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 6.59
MOMs: 3

For me, it seems that Kanu finally got his head around what it takes to play for a struggling side. Having always played for sides used to winning, I think the Nigerian found it difficult to adjust to not winning quite as often. But this season, he produced his best form for Albion and my main regret is that he wasn't used often enough. His absence during January was a big loss, but I do feel that Robson should have used Kanu in place of Campbell far more frequently as, in tight games, Kanu is the sort of player that can produce that bit of magic that can win the game; and without Gera, he's been about the only one that has that ability.

The odds are that Kanu will depart for pastures new this summer, but as I write, talks are still ongoing. If there is someway we can keep him at the Hawthorns, he would be a major asset next season.

^ Back to Top


26 - Rob Davies
Appearances: 0+1 (FAC)
Goals: 0
Yellow Cards: 0
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 7.00
MOMs: 0

A single first team appearance in the defeat to Reading is a step forward for the young midfielder - it remains to be seen whether he is good enough to push for a more regular squad place next season.

^ Back to Top


28 - Jared Hodgkiss
Appearances: 0+1 (L), 1 (FAC)
Goals: 0
Yellow Cards: 0
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 6.50
MOMs: 0

Young right back Hodgkiss looked entirely at home on both occasions that he played for the first team this season, and he looks like an excellent prospect. I expect him to be far more involved next term.

^ Back to Top


29 - Tomasz Kuszczak
Appearances: 28 (L), 2 (CC)
Clean Sheets: 8
Yellow Cards: 0
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 6.59
MOMs: 2

Tommy can count himself a little unlucky not be first first choice at the beginning of the season following his impressive performances in the tail end of the previous one, but once he got his chance, he grabbed hold of it with both hands. The error at White Hart Lane aside, he had a fantastic season and deservedly won the BBC Save of the Season Competition with that amazing stop to deny Jason Roberts in the dying minutes of the match at the JJB. His form has won him a place in the Polish World Cup squad ahead of Jerzy Dudek and has apparently attracted the interest of Sir Alex Ferguson. We all hope our Pole in Goal will stay a Baggie and perhaps challenge for Russell Hoult's clean sheet record next season!!

^ Back to Top


31 - Stuart Nicholson
Appearances: 0+4 (L), 0+1 (FAC)
Goals: 0
Yellow Cards: 0
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 6.20
MOMs: 0

Stuart Nicholson's goalscoring record in the reserves earned him a first team call up which has resulted in him making five first team appearances, all in difficult situations. He has not disgraced himself at all, and has shown an abundance of pace and enthusiasm and not lack of footballing intelligence with some excellent movement. Next season could be a big one for him.

^ Back to Top


33 - Junichi Inamoto
Appearances: 16+6 (L), 2 (CC), 2 (FAC)
Goals: 1
Yellow Cards: 1
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: 6.38
MOMs: 3

Albion's second representative in this summer's World Cup, Ina has had a mixed season. He did not deserve to be frozen out after a good opening day performance at Man City, and a decent display at Chelsea, but Robson asked him to improve certain aspects of his game and the Japanese international got his head down and worked hard. That hard work was rewarded with a recall for the game against his old club in the Carling Cup which he ran from start to finish and won with an amazing strike in extra time. Other than that, Ina produced mixed performances, sometimes excellent, sometimes anonymous, which must have been supremely frustrating for the manager.

He's asked to be given some form a guarantee of first team football next season which, with Carter, Chaplow, Quashie and Wallwork all fighting for two central midfield places, he is unlikely to get. I would not, therefore, be surprised to see Ina move on in the summer.
^ Back to Top


Darren Moore
Appearances: 3+2 (L), 3 (CC), 1 (FAC)
Goals: 0
Yellow Cards: 0
Red Cards: 1

Average Rating: 5.29
MOMs: -

It was a shame that Big Dave's Albion career should have finished with such a dreadful moment, but noone will ever forget the fantastic impact he had on the club and community in his time at the Hawthorns. He was never really up to it this season from footballing viewpoint, but his presence at the club is sorely missed.

^ Back to Top


Jason Koumas
Appearances: 0
Goals: 0
Yellow Cards: 0
Red Cards: 0

Average Rating: -
MOMs: 0

A successful loan period at Cardiff looks likely to have secured JK's permanent move away from the Hawthorns although, at the time of writing, Cardiff seem reluctant to part with the agreed fee. Robson has said that Koumas would be welcome back at the Hawthorns should the deal not take place, but it would seem unlikely that such feelings would be reciprocated. Personally, I would welcome a properly motivated and professional Koumas back at the Hawthorns as he is an amazingly skilful player, but he would need to eat a large slice of humble pie to make that happen which he has so far been unable to do. His desire to be a big fish in a small pond looks likely to win the day.

^ Back to Top


Manager - Bryan Robson
Average Rating: 6.40

The euphoria of last season is long forgotten and Bryan Robson's performance has come under close scrutiny this season. Failed squad rotation, defensive tactics and an apparent inability to drop players who were underperforming are valid criticisms that can be levelled at Albion's manager this season. His performance in the transfer market can also be questioned, as can his ability to deal with problem players such as Robert Earnshaw. It is very difficult to argue that Robson has done a good job this season, but Jeremy Peace has decided that he hasn't done a bad enough one to merit his dismissal.

I maintain that Albion have played some great football under Robson and produced some superb performances this season - the biggest problem has been consistency. Robson will get my full support next season - I believe he deserves the chance to put right what went wrong this season.

^ Back to Top