jonwant.com
jonwant.com Home Page Links to other footy sites Links to other footy sites Links to non-footy related sites. Photo features Contact the webmaster.
Reading v West Bromwich Albion
Madejski Stadium, Reading. 1st May 2004, 3.00pm.
Back to Reports Menu


It was a remarkable display from the Albion fans as something like three quarters of the away support made some effort to dress up to honour the Great Dane, although the atmosphere went a little flat late on as Steve Sidwell's winner all but destroyed Albion's title hopes.

With promotion secured, Megson decided to rest Andy Johnson who had been playing for the last few weeks with an injury, and with Koumas suspended, the midfield had an unfamiliar look. Dyer was granted his league first start in place of Koumas, with O'Connor taking AJ's place alongside Kinsella. The only other change to the starting line-up saw Darren Moore return to the back three in place of Neil Clement, who dropped to the bench.

As against Bradford last week, the match was more of a side show than the main event as the Viking hordes sang their way through a largely disappointing first half.

Hughes had a good chance when he picked up a pass from O'Connor before beating two players and firing wide. Moore also had a sight of goal from O'Connor's free kick but his header was deflected wide.

However, it was the home side that looked to take control of the match and Moore had to be on his best form to deny Goater and Kitson as the Royals put the Baggies under some concerted pressure.

Robinson was called into action with a great tackle to prevent Sidwell having a clear shooting chance, and Big Dave was on hand minutes later to deny Kitson once more.

Chambers had a rare attempt on goal when he was first to a Gregan knock down, but his shot was deflected wide by Andy Hughes.

Back at the other end, Murty shot wide and Sidwell saw a header blocked before half time saw some respite for the Baggies.

Horsfield had obviously been struggling in the first half and was replaced by Dobie at half time. It made little difference to the overall pattern of the game as Reading continued to make the better chances.

Kitson saw an effort from a tight angle blocked by Hoult before Andy Hughes headed over with the goal gaping. Kitson was guilty of a similar opportunity minutes later before Megson made another change bringing Sakiri on for Lee Hughes.

Albion finally showed some quality with the best move of the match on 68 minutes when Dyer, Kinsella and Sakiri combined well to put Chambers through on the right side and his low cross evaded Dobie but fell for Dyer at the back post but he could only fined the side netting from tight angle.

Kitson failed to hit the target once again with eight minutes to go before Albion looked to try and win the game. They started to put some passes together and push forward before they were caught with two minutes to go. With defenders committed forward, the ball was lost and suddenly Sidwell was breaking with Reading with a three on two advantage. But as he advanced towards the Albion area with a teammate either side, SIDWELL ignored them and struck a fierce shot from the edge of the box which went in off the post with Hoult unmoved. It was an excellent finish, but questions must be asked as to the whereabouts of the Albion defence.

With promotion secured, the result was of limited importance for the Baggies, but a poor display serves to highlight the work that must be done on improving the squad for next year.


RESULT - READING 1 WEST BROMWICH ALBION 0

Marks

Hoult - 6 - One or two dodgy moments.
Gaardsoe - 7 - Generally solid if unspectacular.
Moore - 8 - Good solid display from Big Dave.
Gregan - 7 - Solid.
J Chambers - 5 - Poor display; naive at times and wasteful with possession.
O'Connor - 5 - Slow in thought, got caught far too often; a poor substitute for AJ.
Kinsella - 8 - MOM. His experience keeps shining through with his intelligent use of the ball; should have earned a new contract.
Dyer - 6 - One or two good moments, but his lack of experience showed through on occasion.
Robinson - 7 - Another good showing from Robbo.
Hughes - 6 - Failed to really sparkle.
Horsfield - 6 - Surprised to see him start as his injury is obviously troubling him.

Dobie - 5 - Failed to add anything; seems to have lost some sparkle somewhere and is often knocked off the ball too easily.
Sakiri - 6 - Never got in to the game much.
Clement - 7 - Did a good job.

The Manager - 6 - Don't understand how O'Connor started, nor how he played ninety minutes. Horsfield should've been rested, why not Facey instead of Dobie on the bench? Sakiri for Hughes was a strange substitution. Not one of his better days.


Reading (4-4-2):
Ashdown; Murty, Williams, Newman, A Hughes; Savage (Morgan 65), Harper, Sidwell, Solako (Gordon 45); Kitson, Goater (Brooker 65). Subs not used: Hahnemann (GK), Owusu.
West Bromwich Albion (3-5-2):
Hoult; Gaardsoe, Moore, Gregan; J Chambers, O'Connor, Kinsella, Dyer, Robinson (Clement 60); Hughes (Sakiri 54), Horsfield (Dobie 45). Subs not used: Murphy (GK), Haas.
Scoring: Sidwell (88) 1-0.
Bookings: Reading - Newman (foul 14), Kitson (foul 90+3). West Bromwich Albion - Chambers (foul 18), O'Connor (foul 43), Moore (foul 71).

Referee: C Penton (Sussex).
Attendance: 20,619.
^ Back to Top